8 Best Places to Sell Video Games for Cash in 2026

Used video games can be worth real money, whether they’re old cartridges in a closet or newer disc games you’ve finished. A boxed GameCube game, a stack of PS2 titles, or a working Sega Genesis can sell for more than most people expect. The hard part is picking where to sell.

No single buyer pays the most for every game. The places below are picked for different seller needs: sending in a whole collection, selling one valuable game at a time, or selling in person. Use the table to find your fit, then read the details.

Quick Comparison

Where	How it works	How you get paid	Best for
eBay	You list and ship to buyers	Bank payout after fees	Selling valuable games one at a time
DKOldies	Mail-in buyer with a posted price list	PayPal, check, store credit	Seeing prices up front, especially for store credit
The Old School Game Vault	Nationwide mail-in buyer	PayPal, Zelle, Venmo, Apple Cash, check, Amazon Gift Card	Selling a collection by mail with upfront cash offers
eStarland	Mail-in buyer	Store credit or cash payout	Mixed retro and modern lots, including imports
Retro Game Fan	Mail-in buyer, quote by photos	eCheck, PayPal, store credit	Larger collections in good shape
Game Over Videogames	Mail-in or in store	Check, PayPal, cash in store	A quick online estimate, or selling near a store
PayMore	In store	Cash	Same-day cash near a store
Local game stores	In store	Cash or store credit	Selling face to face

1. eBay

How it works: eBay is the biggest marketplace for used and retro games. You take the photos, write the listing, answer questions, pack the box, and ship each item. So many collectors search it that rare titles can sell for top dollar.

Payment: eBay sends your sale money to your bank account after its fees.

Key restrictions: eBay takes a cut of each sale, and you may have to handle returns. Listing a box of common games one by one takes a lot of time.

Best for: Selling valuable games individually.

2. DKOldies

How it works: DKOldies is a retro game store in Morgantown, Pennsylvania, that also buys games by mail. It posts a price list that updates every week, with arrows showing which prices went up or down. You pick your items, or email a list of anything not shown, and get a quote within one business day.

Payment: PayPal, paper check, or store credit with a 20% bonus. PayPal and store credit are paid within one business day after your items are checked in, and checks take a few days longer.

Key restrictions: Shipping is free on quotes over $20. Your price list is only good if you ship within two business days. Prices are for cartridges only unless noted, and disc games and DS games need the original case and manual. They only buy North American (NTSC) games, all sales are final, and damaged items are not sent back.

Best for: Sellers who want to see prices up front, especially if they plan to use store credit.

3. The Old School Game Vault

How it works: The Old School Game Vault has been buying and selling retro video games online since 2008 and accepts mail-in orders from sellers across the US. You search a catalog of 22,000+ games, consoles, and accessories, see a cash offer online, and ship your items in. Your quote stays valid for 10 business days, and every item is tested when it arrives. The company has an A+ BBB rating and strong customer reviews across several platforms.

Payment: PayPal, Zelle, Venmo, Apple Cash, check, or Amazon Gift Card, sent within 3 to 4 business days after your order is received and processed. The offers you see are cash prices, not store credit.

Key restrictions: A $100 minimum order is required. Shipping is free on orders over $100. It buys games and consoles from NES through PS4, including loose cartridges, but not loose discs for disc-based systems. It does not buy PS5 or Xbox Series X/S. Items that don’t meet its standards are flagged first and can be sent back.

Best for: Selling a collection through a nationwide mail-in service with upfront cash offers.

4. eStarland

How it works: eStarland has been around since 1991 and runs a trade-in catalog of more than 40,000 items. You search for your games, see a price right away, and ship them in. Bulk lots and imports go through a custom quote form.

Payment: Store credit, or a cash balance in your account that you can request as a payout.

Key restrictions: A free shipping label is available on some trades, not all.

Best for: Mixed lots of retro and modern games, including imports.

5. Retro Game Fan

How it works: Retro Game Fan is an online store in Georgia that buys retro games by mail. You fill out a form, upload photos, and get a quote, usually within a day or two. If you accept, they email a prepaid USPS label.

Payment: eCheck with no fee, PayPal with a 2.9% fee, or store credit with a 10% bonus.

Key restrictions: Their program works best for larger collections in good condition, so single games or worn items are usually not a fit. Disc games need the original case and artwork, and they only buy North American (NTSC) games. Items they turn down are sent back for a flat $10 fee or recycled.

Best for: Larger collections in good shape.

6. Game Over Videogames

How it works: Game Over is a retro game chain based in Austin, Texas. Its website has an automated mail-in quote tool covering everything from Atari to Xbox. You print the quote, sign it, and ship your games in. If you live near a store, they suggest bringing items in for an exact offer.

Payment: Check or PayPal for mail-in trades, sent within 10 days after they test your items. Stores also pay cash or store credit in person.

Key restrictions: You pay for shipping yourself. Disc games need the box, cover art, and manual for full value.

Best for: A quick online estimate, or selling near a Game Over store.

7. PayMore

How it works: PayMore is a chain of electronics buy-and-sell stores with locations around the country. Staff look at video games and consoles along with phones, laptops, and tablets.

Payment: Cash on the spot.

Key restrictions: In store only. PayMore buys all kinds of electronics, so it is a generalist, not a retro specialist, and it only pays for items with resale value.

Best for: Same-day cash if there’s a store near you.

8. Your Local Game Store

How it works: Many towns have an independent game shop that buys used and retro games over the counter. There’s no shipping, and you can watch them look over your games and ask questions about the offer.

Payment: Cash or store credit. Most shops pay more in store credit.

Key restrictions: Offers depend on what each store needs right now, so two shops in the same city can quote very different prices.

Best for: Selling face to face.

How to Price Your Games Before You Sell

Knowing what your games are worth helps you spot a fair offer and decide if selling them yourself is worth the work.

Look at completed sales, not asking prices. On eBay, search for your game and turn on the “Sold Items” filter. Those are prices people actually paid. Active listings only show what sellers hope to get, and many of them sit for months without selling. Price tracking sites built on sales data can also give you a quick average.

Match the exact version. Compare the same game, on the same system, in the same edition. A Player’s Choice or Greatest Hits copy can sell for a different price than the original release. A PAL or Japanese copy is priced differently from a North American one.

Be honest about condition. Condition changes value more than almost anything else. A loose cartridge, a game with its box, and a complete copy with the box and manual can sell for very different prices. Torn labels, cracked cases, missing manuals, scratched discs, and games that don’t work all lower the price.

Subtract fees. Selling it yourself means the sale price is not what you keep. Marketplaces take a percentage of each sale, and payment processing can add more. Check the current fee rates before you list.

Count shipping and packing costs. Padded mailers, boxes, and postage add up, and consoles cost a lot more to ship than a single cartridge. If a buyer offers free shipping above a set order amount, that’s money you keep.

Here’s a simple example. A game that sells for $60 on eBay might leave you around $45 to $50 after fees, shipping, and a mailer. If a mail-in buyer offers $42 with free shipping and no listing work, the gap is smaller than it first looks. On one valuable game, selling it yourself may still win. On a box of 30 common games, a single offer usually saves a lot of time.

How to Sell Video Games Safely

A few simple habits protect you whether you sell to a company or to another person.

Check the buyer first. Read recent customer reviews and look up their BBB rating. Make sure they list a real address and phone number.

Read the rules before you ship. Know how and when you’ll be paid, how long your quote lasts, and what happens to items they turn down.

Keep records. Save a copy or screenshot of your quote. Take photos of your games before you pack them, including labels and any damage.

Ship with tracking. Always use a tracking number and add insurance on valuable packages. Pack games so they can’t slide around in the box.

Stay on the platform. When selling on a marketplace like eBay, keep all messages and payments inside the site. Be careful if a buyer asks to pay another way, wants you to ship to a different address, or sends a link asking you to log in somewhere.

Meet in safe places. If you sell to someone in person, meet in a busy public spot during the day, or sell to a store instead.

4 Questions to Ask Before You Sell

Do they pay cash, store credit, or both? Many buyers pay more in store credit. That’s a good deal if you plan to shop there. If you want money you can spend anywhere, compare the cash offers only.

What happens to items they turn down? Some buyers send rejected items back. Some charge a fee to return them. Some keep or recycle them. Know the rule before you ship something valuable.

How long does your quote last? Some quotes last two days. Others give you two weeks. A longer window lets you pack at your own pace without prices changing on you.

Do they know how to spot fakes? Reproduction cartridges are common. A buyer with real authentication experience will value your genuine games fairly and won’t lump them in with fakes.

What About Gameflip and Swappa?

Both show up on lists like this one. They are marketplaces, not buyers. You only get paid after another person buys your item, and you handle the shipping. Gameflip is mostly used for digital codes, gift cards, and newer games, and Swappa focuses on phones and modern electronics. Retro activity on both can be thin, so search for your own titles there before you plan on selling that way.

How to Pick

If you’re selling a collection, a mail-in buyer saves you from listing and shipping each game yourself. If you have one valuable game and time to spare, eBay often gets the highest price for that single item. If there’s a good game shop near you, get a local quote too and compare.

Before you sell anywhere, check each buyer’s condition rules. Missing cases, torn labels, and non-working items lower offers almost everywhere.

Frequently Asked Questions

Where can I sell video games online for cash?

You can sell directly to other buyers on eBay or use a mail-in buying service such as The Old School Game Vault, DKOldies, eStarland, Retro Game Fan, or Game Over Videogames. Compare cash offers, accepted systems, shipping costs, and condition rules before choosing.

How can I sell used video games online safely?

Check recent customer reviews and the buyer’s BBB rating, read their payment and rejection policies, and save a copy of your quote. Photograph your games before packing and use tracked shipping. When selling on a marketplace, keep all messages and payments inside the platform.

How do I accurately price my video games for selling online?

Look up completed sales for the same game, system, edition, and condition. Asking prices on active listings don’t tell you what buyers actually paid. Adjust for missing cases, manuals, or damage, then subtract selling fees and shipping costs to see what you’ll really keep.

Which platforms offer the highest payouts for selling video games?

Selling one game at a time on eBay can bring the highest price for valuable titles, but fees, shipping, and your time cut into that. Mail-in buyers offer a simpler way to sell a whole collection. Compare several cash quotes against what you’d keep after selling each game yourself.